Horstman's Wager

There are interviewees who believe that the key to interviewing is to "play the game."

There isn't something like that. Basically, these people are trying to avoid the hard work of preparation.

Interviewing is often seen as a black box, leaving candidates uncertain about what will lead to success. Some believe that "playing the game"—shaping their answers to fit what they assume an employer wants—will improve their chances. However, Horstman’s Wager challenges this notion, arguing that preparation and authenticity are far superior to deception. While myths about interview success persist, they often lead candidates astray, encouraging shortcuts that rarely pay off.

The episode introduces a 2x2 matrix to illustrate possible interview outcomes. Candidates who prepare thoroughly and remain authentic either get an offer (Quadrant 1) or don’t (Quadrant 2), but both results lead to clarity and better long-term career fit. Conversely, those who "play the game" may receive an offer (Quadrant 3) but often find themselves in jobs that don't suit them, leading to dissatisfaction. The worst-case scenario (Quadrant 4) is when a candidate plays the game and still doesn’t get an offer, leaving them wondering whether honesty and preparation would have made the difference.

Ultimately, the takeaway is clear: preparation and integrity are the surest paths to interview success. Hired! The Interview Series provides insights into how structured preparation leads to not just more offers, but the right offers. Whether you’re job hunting now or in the future, the principles in this episode will help you secure roles that truly align with your skills and values.

Sign up below to unlock the podcast and full content on this page—everything you need to master your interview and get hired.

If you’re already a member, enjoy the content!